Category: Business

  • Number One? No thanks!

    The Financial Times reports that China is set to become, if it has not already become, the world’s largest economy in 2014, based on purchasing power. But interestingly it is reported that China has been engaged in a long campaign to suppress the figures.

    If we accept that China disagreed with the figures (without the use of the kind of emotive language to be found in the Times article), the question immediately comes to mind – why? The principle argument given in the article is that China does not want the additional responsibilities that being number one would bring. But are the additional responsibilities from being number two to being number one really the cause? More likely, as hinted at in the article, but not examined in any detail, the reason is far more about perceptions than it is about responsibilities.

    What in fact really matters to China, the Chinese government and the Chinese people is the living standards enjoyed by Chinese citizens. Deng Xiaoping, once said, “Socialism is not poverty.” And by putting the economic development of China as the overriding priority, he embarked China upon a century-old dream of modernization and standing tall once more.

    Nobody coud have envisaged the remarkable success of Deng’s Open Door and Reform policies would achieve. To come from nowhere and then ‘threaten’ the world’s leading economies’ positions brings with it significant political risks. One has only to look at the anti-China rhetoric that comes from some quarters in the US to see that China, despite every effort not to rock the boat with the USA, is actually stuck between a rock and a hard place. Its priority must be the welfare of its own people, and that has been served through rapid economic development – even those who have been ‘left behind’ are better off than they were. But a strong China is seen by some as a threat, not last of all in the US.

    This is a far better explanation of Chinas reluctance to be declared the world’s largest economy by purchasing power. And in truth, with China actually the 99th economy in the world in terms of GDP per capita, the Chinese government knows the purchasing power number one slot brings nothing but the political problems it generates from a disgruntled United States.

    Powered By WordPress | Seopage

  • Caught in the middle

    The US Congress has deemed that the two Chinese telecoms companies, Huawei and ZTE pose a security threat to the US, and recommended that the two companies should not be allowed to take part in any US mergers or acquisitions.

    Based on available classified and unclassified information, Huawei and ZTE cannot be trusted to be free of foreign state influence and thus pose a security threat to the United States and to our systems.

    The panel said their investigation had received credible allegations from current and former Huawei employees of bribery and corruption, discriminatory behaviour and copyright infringement.

    Of course we are in the midst of the US presidential election campaigns, and China has (once again) become a central issue. Both Republican and Democratic candidates promise to apply more pressure on Beijing, ranging from the perennial human rights issues to the laboured, though clearly entrenched views on the value of the Yuan. Being tough on China is a vote winner.

    But whereas China has never accused any American enterprises of any complicity with its government, China has taken a broadly similar stand in regards to some usage of American software, and in particular the Chinese government made a conscious decision not to use Microsoft Windows and Office products within government. Whereas some may see this as a shrewd move for technical reasons, the decision was guided by national security concerns. Microsoft lost out, but on the plus side it was a huge boost for China’s chosen operating system, Linux. Being open source, the Chinese could see exactly what was being installed on their computers.

    Are there any truths to the allegations? The two companies concerned naturally say not. What is telling is that the Congressional Committee actually stops short of calling for a boycott of the products. This would suggest that the evidence is at best circumstantial if we assume that any hard evidence would lead to such a call. This is further supported by the use of the word “credible allegations.” Credible and true are far from the same.

    Once again the notion of a threat to national security appears to be being used as the ultimate beating stick which people find hard to challenge.

    Meanwhile, back in China responses ranging from calls to boycott Apple to allegations that this is yet one more attempt by the USA to proactively prevent Chinas development.

    Whatever the truth of the matter, until trust between the world’s two largest economies rises beyond the sceptical it is likely that businesses will continue to be caught in the middle.

  • Dumping

    Once again Chinese companies stand accused of dumping goods in Europe. This time it’s solar panels. What makes this incident different from the others is the value of the exports, some £16 billion plus. It will be almost another year until the EU gives its verdict, whilst the US has already slapped import duties following a similar complaint in the States. Worryingly the Chinese are strongly hinting that they aren’t going to take this lying down, and some retaliatory measure would follow any EU sanctions. But how much of this is a bluff on the part of the Chinese? China seeks to adjust its economic growth model, looking to switch its reliance on exports to domestic consumption. The task is monumental enough as it is without the further complication of a trade war with the European Union and the US.

    The truth remains that Chinas success is linked to our own. European manufacturers should be protected from unfair competition from China or elsewhere. Hand in hand with that is the need to promote a win-win situation for everyone. Restricting trade with China leaves everyone a loser.

  • Working in our own interest

    The story that China is likely to be involved in developing Britain’s nuclear power capacity has been around for some time. It is an interesting thought, given that Home Secretary, Theressa May, recently expressed national security concerns over Chinese nationals. According to the Guardian,

    In May, the energy minister Charles Hendry told the Energy and Climate Change select committee that he had no objection to Chinese firms being involved in the UK.

    So what is going on? One thing that definitely isn’t going on is joined up government. For all the criticism that the Chinese government gets, there’s no doubting that there is some consistency in its approach, and a sense, at least, that it is working to some strategic plan. Deng Xiaoping’s metaphor of crossing a river by feeling the stones suggests that there was no clear strategy to China’s reform programme. Yet some thirty-plus years on we’re talking about China’s possible involvement in building nuclear power stations in the UK.

    Undoubtedly the world is complex. There will be a difference of opinion in government. But some issues are of national strategic importance. I would suggest that the relationship with China is one such issue. As we explain in may of our training courses, trust lies at the heart of relationships in China, whether between individuals, companies or indeed governments. Understanding how relationships work in Chinese culture is not difficut, but something which few people take the time to acquire properly. But for those who really want to get the most out of working, trading, living or dealing with the Chinese, acquiring that understanding should be high up on their agenda, and that includes within government.

    The criticism may be levied that this is just pandering to the Chinese. I’m not going to split hairs, in many ways, yes it is. But there’s a bigger picture to see. It is about working in our own interest, be that national, corporate or personal. And what’s the alternative? Demanding that the Chinese adopt our cultural norms or we don’t engage? Not only is that incredibly short sighted, but ultimately is a misreading of the way the world is today. And if that thought is foolhardy for today, then it is sheer madness for tomorrow.

  • Time to smell?

    The Financial Times reports that Paul Smith announces he is returning to the Chinese market after pulling out some five years ago.

    Sir Paul must surely at least have slightly raised an eyebrow at reports from rival British firm Burberry, which reported China as second only to the US for sales, with one of its best selling lines in China being an iPad cover costing £2,495 (more on this in the next post, Vain?).

    With China’s middle class racing to be added to the list of China’s catalogue of world’s largest, the lure of the Chinese market is self-evident, even for those who have been badly bitten by it in the past. There are two important things to draw from this. First, just how strong the gravitational pull of the Chinese market is. Paul Smith pulled out of China in 2007 after heavy losses, calling it “dangerous’. Despite such a history he is being drawn back east. Second, that we need to adjust our concept of time when we look at China. In what would seem a very short time in western markets, the whole landscape will have changed in China. As such, it may very well be time to smell.

  • Business sense versus the Yellow Peril.

    The business case for encouraging more Chinese tourists to the UK appears not to be strong enough to convince Home Secretary Theressa May, to make it easier for Chinese tourists to enter the UK, worryingly raising the ghost of the ‘yellow peril’ by citing national security concerns.

    A tourist visiting Britain will spend an average of£567, however, Chinese tourists spend three times that amount, averaging £1,700. Had the same number of Chinese tourists visited Britian as France last year it would have injected an extra £1,786,700,000 (yes, almost £1.8 billion) into the British economy; but it is not just the loss of a much-needed boost to the economy that should concern us.

    Suggesting that the Chinese people pose a threat to national security is difficult to understand. Neither France, Germany nor any of the twenty-plus countries that require just a single Schengen visa to visit have such qualms. Even the twitchy USA employed an extra 50 visa processing staff at its Beijing Embassy earlier this year and relaxed its visa requirements in order to attract more Chinese tourists, so no sign of any “national security” concerns there either! Sadly we should be under no doubt that the Home Secretary’s words will be heard in Beijing, and they won’t be making Britain any friends.

    Meanwhile Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt, has just launched an £8m campaign to try to attract more Chinese tourists to the UK. Last year 1.2 million Chinese tourists traveled as far as France; getting them across the Channel surely can’t be that hard… except they won’t have visas!

    What we are left with is a lose-lose situation, with a gratuitous face-losing swipe at the Chinese thrown in for good measure. With regret we return to a familiar sight, with an avoidable lack of understanding of China and the Chinese once again resulting in unnecessary damage to Britain’s standing with such an important economic partner.