Month: October 2012

  • China’s soft power

    China’s soft power is arguably weak, at least if you are to listen to voices within China. Recently the press in China have asking why China can’t produce a global hit as Korea has done in PSY’s Gangnam Style. The press lament the fact that the Chinese can only copy (parody) the song.

    But is China’s soft power really that weak? It is one of the great paradoxes of British Chinese life that the Chinese community at one and the same time is culturally open and culutrally closed. It’s openness is demonstrated in its sharing of Chinese culture and traditions, from martial arts to Chinese New Year, traditional Chinese medicine to Feng Shui, and of course the ubiquitous nature of Chinese food. Indeed, it is difficult to think of another culture that has so visibly impacted upon British cultural life either in breadth or in depth as the Chinese.

    Capitalising on the cultural foundations established by overseas Chinese communities is certainly one way hat China could at the very least raise its own understanding of its position in the world in regards to soft power – perhaps then there would be less lamenting and more developing?

  • Scapegoating China

    China features highly in the US elections, with neither Republican nor Democrats wanting to be seen to be soft on “Red China”. The evils of China range from spy networks, cyber crimes and stealing American jobs to trade deficits, undervalued Yuan and China’s holding of US debt. The issue has led Chinas official news agency, Xinhua, to warn that Sino-US relations could be damaged.

    Bloomberg has reported that China is set to loose its position as the US’s biggest foreign creditor. Will this stop the China-bashing back in the US? Unlikley. It probably won’t even stop the table thumping in outrage of lending from the communists. It’s election year in the US, and yes, we can expect politicians to be pampering to various constituents, including those holding anti-China sentiments. But surely there is some need to preserve good relations with China too. As the world’s two largest economies we all have an interest in this happening.

  • Caught in the middle

    The US Congress has deemed that the two Chinese telecoms companies, Huawei and ZTE pose a security threat to the US, and recommended that the two companies should not be allowed to take part in any US mergers or acquisitions.

    Based on available classified and unclassified information, Huawei and ZTE cannot be trusted to be free of foreign state influence and thus pose a security threat to the United States and to our systems.

    The panel said their investigation had received credible allegations from current and former Huawei employees of bribery and corruption, discriminatory behaviour and copyright infringement.

    Of course we are in the midst of the US presidential election campaigns, and China has (once again) become a central issue. Both Republican and Democratic candidates promise to apply more pressure on Beijing, ranging from the perennial human rights issues to the laboured, though clearly entrenched views on the value of the Yuan. Being tough on China is a vote winner.

    But whereas China has never accused any American enterprises of any complicity with its government, China has taken a broadly similar stand in regards to some usage of American software, and in particular the Chinese government made a conscious decision not to use Microsoft Windows and Office products within government. Whereas some may see this as a shrewd move for technical reasons, the decision was guided by national security concerns. Microsoft lost out, but on the plus side it was a huge boost for China’s chosen operating system, Linux. Being open source, the Chinese could see exactly what was being installed on their computers.

    Are there any truths to the allegations? The two companies concerned naturally say not. What is telling is that the Congressional Committee actually stops short of calling for a boycott of the products. This would suggest that the evidence is at best circumstantial if we assume that any hard evidence would lead to such a call. This is further supported by the use of the word “credible allegations.” Credible and true are far from the same.

    Once again the notion of a threat to national security appears to be being used as the ultimate beating stick which people find hard to challenge.

    Meanwhile, back in China responses ranging from calls to boycott Apple to allegations that this is yet one more attempt by the USA to proactively prevent Chinas development.

    Whatever the truth of the matter, until trust between the world’s two largest economies rises beyond the sceptical it is likely that businesses will continue to be caught in the middle.

  • Bo Xilai – understanding the process

    In understanding the Bo Xilai case we need to first understand why the case is so important in China. Mr Bo was one of Chinas top ranking members of government, poised to take a seat on the all powerful Politburo Standing Committee. Although not tipped (or destined) for the top post, equivalent to Prime Minister in the UK, he was heading for one of the top positions in government, equivalent in the UK to being made Chancellor of the Exchequer, Home Secretary or Foreign Secretary – a position of considerable power, and why his case raises so many questions in China. But Mr Bo’s political career is no over as Xinhua Newsagency, the official newsagency of China, has announced that Bo Xilai is to be expelled from the Communist Party of China (CPC).

    The Political Bureau of the CPC Central Committee decided at the meeting to expel Bo from the Party in accordance with the Party Constitution and CPC intra-party supervisory disciplinary regulations. The Party sanctions will be endorsed by the 7th plenary meeting of the 17th CPC Central Committee, which will be held ahead of the Party’s 18th National Congress set to convene on Nov. 8.

    The Political Bureau of the CPC Central Committee has also decided to remove Bo from public office in accordance with the country’s Law on Public Servants and to transfer Bo’s suspected law violations and relevant evidence to judicial organs for handling.

    In short Bo Xilai is being expelled from the party, removed from office and allegations investigated by the police. It all seems straight forward enough (although this surface view masks the intense debates that must have happened within the Party before this course of action was finally agreed upon). It ends Mr Bo’s political career, and a long jail sentence is likely if he is found guilty.

    But to truly understand what has happened, and to understand why this matter is not as straight forward as it seems we need to understand the process – not simply the outcome. Key to this is understanding that for members of the CPC transgressions of the law are a matter of Party discipline, not legal process. That is to say, had Mr Bo remained a Party member, all the allegations could have been handled internally by the Party.

    It is easy to assume that the “transfer [of] Bo’s suspected law violations and relevant evidence to judicial organs for handling” is a natural part of the judicial process, as would be the case in the UK. It is not. There has already been an investigation, the case has been heard (by The Political Bureau of the CPC Central Committee) and a judgment has been handed out – expulsion, removal from office and the case being handed over to the police. The Political Bureau of the CPC Central Committee could have stopped at expulsion and removal had it so wished.

    When dealing with China it is important that we don’t simply transpose our own systems and processes to China. Even if, as in this case, things look very similar on the surface, differences in how things are done, said or approached, can be significant. Highlighting and explaining these differences lie at the heart of our China Training courses.