Tag: Taiwan

  • The Taiwan Question

    Representatives of China and Taiwan formally met today (11th February 2014) for the first time in 65 years. It is an historic occasion, a pragmatic (if difficult step) in the ever-closer relationship between the mainland and Taiwan. But what is the back ground to the Taiwan question.

    Aboriginal peoples have from ancient times inhabited Taiwan, with Han Chinese relocating to the island form the 7th Century onwards. In the modern era it was the Portuguese in the 16th Century who “discovered” the island, and called it Formosa (Beautiful). But it was the Dutch, and shortly afterwards the Spanish that formed colonies on the island during the early part of the 17th Century.

    When the Ming Dynasty was overthrown, some loyalists to the Ming regime set up administration in part of the island, but the Qing Court gained control of the island in 1683, but it was another 200 years, in 1885, before Taiwan was designated China’s 22nd Province. But this status came abruptly to an end in 1895, when, following China’s defeat in the First Sino-Japanese War (1894-1895) the island was ceded to Japan.

    Following Japan’s defeat at the end of World War II Taiwan was returned to China in 1945. Soon after the civil war broke out between the ruling Kuomingtang (KMT) – Nationalist Party, and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). The KMT were eventually pushed to the peripheral areas of China, most notably the islands of Hainan and Taiwan. The CCP declared the founding of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) on 1st October 1949, even though these two areas remained under the control of the KMT.

    In the spring of 1950 the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) retook Hainan Island and were poised to make an assault on Taiwan. But just at that point the PRC became embroiled in the Korean War. The United States, who had until this point kept out of the civil war, sent its navy to the Taiwan Straits and prevented the amphibious assault taking place.

    From their island stronghold, protected by the US, the KMT asserted that they, and they alone, as the government of the Republic of China, remained the sole legitimate government of the whole of China, and vowed to retake the mainland. The United Nations recognised the ROC as the legitimate government of China until 1971. As the Republic of China, Taiwan maintains its position as the sole legitimate government of China, although the diplomatic battle for recognition was lost a long time ago. Today just 20 countries recognise the ROC as China.

    But this is not a position shared by some opposition parties in Taiwan, some of whom advocate and independent state of Taiwan. Such talk became so loud in 2003-4 that the PRC responded in 2005 with an anti-cessation law that formally declared the PRC would use non-peaceful means to reunify Taiwan with the mainland if it were ever to declare independence.

    With the PRC’s Open Door Policy there was massive investment from Taiwan and gradually direct contact was allowed, including direct postal, shipping and aviation links. In 2008 the PRC and Taiwan effectively agreed not to vie for diplomatic recognition“z – effectively freezing the diplomatic position at that point in time. The PRC, with its growing economic and political strength has had to actively turn down requests for the establishment of diplomatic relations in order to keep to this agreement. Of late the situation has been complicated by Gambia severing diplomatic links with Taiwan; but the PRC have remained resolute and refused to establish diplomatic relations with them – it is clear where the PRC’s priority lie.

    There remains, however, some distance to travel in terms of a popular movement in Taiwan for reunification, despite Beijing’s offer of a Hong Kong style One Country to Systems approach. However, it is not all bad news for Beijing, with a majority on Taiwan believing that negotiations regarding reunification should only be undertaken when the conditions are right for Taiwan – indicating that there is an underlying acceptance by the majority that reunification could take place. Meanwhile, on the mainland, Taiwan’s estrangement from the motherland is an extremely sensitive point. The Taiwan question provides the single biggest political divide among the Chinese diaspora.

    As for the PRC, a long game approach has been adopted regarding reunification. For ever the pragmatist, Deng Xiaoping, not anticipating any serious notion of independence, declared, “Reunification of the motherland is the aspiration of the whole nation. If it cannot be accomplished in 100 years, it will be in 1,000 years.”

  • Chinese Taboos

    There are somethings which are better left out of any polite conversation with your Chinese colleagues. Politics isn’t necessarily one of them, unless you mention one of the two T words – Tibet and Taiwan. Both these issues hit at the very heart of Chinese identity. Modern China is in fact smaller in size than in the time of the last imperial dynasty – the Qing, mainly due to the independence of Mongolia – or more accurately outer Mongolia (directions being given from the Chinese side of the Great Wall), and land that was also lost to the Soviet Union at the same time. There remain disputes over relatively small areas of land, most notably the Spratley Islands, claimed by a handful of countries, and Arunachal Pradesh, currently under Indian rule. The relative size of these disputed regions bares no resemblance to the feelings which they arouse – perhaps not unlike the British view of the Falkland Islands.

    Oddly the “question” (as the Chinese call it) of both Taiwan and Tibet is largely answered. Formal policy from Taipei (capital of Taiwan) is that Taiwan is a part of China – and consequently Taiwan, (the Republic of China) also lays claim to the Spratley Islands and Arunachal Pradesh. There is no disagreement from Beijing or Taipei on what is known as the One China Principle. The principle states that there is only one China, and both the mainland and Taiwan are part of it. Disagreement comes only as to who is the legitimate government of China.

    Likewise, official policy of the Dalai Lama is that Tibet is a part of China, and in what he refers to as the “Third Way” the Dalai Lama has sought to break the impasse of the two alternatives – an Independent Tibet and Tibet as an undistinguishable part of Chinese territory – by advocating a Tibet within China but with some genuine autonomy. In this regard the One Country Two Systems approach taken with Hong Kong may suggest what the Dalai Lama has in mind.

    Despite the official positions of those who lay challenge to Beijings absolute sovereignty over Taiwan and Tibet not being the cries for independence many assume, there are, nonetheless, vocal groups who are asking for just that. Such a call is implicit in the name of the Free Tibet movement, whilst politicians on the island of Taiwan have demanded independence as part of election campaigns – although the calls are less evident if elected to office.

    Unless you agree that Taiwan is an inalienable part of China and that the Beijing government is the legitimate government of all China, then this subject should be considered taboo. Similarly, unless you agree that Tibet is an inalienable part of China and that the Beijing government is the legitimate government of all China, including Tibet, then avoid discussing this issue. Your ‘unorthodox’ views will be less than welcome, and more likely than not will receive an unusually strong rebuttal, scorn and ridicule. I’m not suggesting that there is absolutely nobody in China who disagrees with Chinas stance on these issues, but by and large a nationalistic view is held by the huge majority, and in general the very best you can hope for is to embarrass the person you are talking to. Offending or insulting them has a high level of probability.

    But why such sensitivity? One could equally ask why the British hold the Falklands as dearly as they do (though I suspect there is a wider difference of opinion when it comes to the British public’s views on the islands). For sure, there is an element of national pride. But for China there is also the historical context where for just over a hundred years China was at the mercy of foreign powers all taking bits of territory – including Britain’s attempt to take Tibet into its sphere of influence. The period is known to the Chinese (and every Chinese school child) as the Century of Humiliation. Undoubtedly this adds an extra dimension to these issues, with the Chinese blaming themselves for the tragedy – China was weak, and therefore to blame for being exploited by the colonial powers. Today’s response to any suggestion, let alone attempt, to divide China may be an overcompensation for past failings, but the feeling of determination to maintain the integrity of China really can’t be overstated.

    Your political views may mean you have a different point of view, but unless you hold them so strongly that you are prepared to have your business relationships destroyed, it really is better to give the subject a wide berth.