Month: August 2012

  • Vain?

    Much of today’s press on China refers to the slowdown in the Chinese economy. Nine percent, it would seem, is something to be worried about. Yet it was earlier this year that the Chinese government announced a reduction in its growth target. This reduction was often linked to slow growth and crisis in the rest of the world. This may well have had something to do with the decision, but probably wasn’t the major concern. China’s overwhelming issues are domestic, and whereas there are issues of over dependence on exports, and a need to promote domestic consumption, the much larger challenge for China lies in the ever-increasing disparity between rich and poor. In our post Time to smell? we reported on Burberry’s claim that one of its top selling items in China was a £2495 iPad cover. Such wealth is not in itself the issue, but when you consider that it could well be be cheaper to employ someone to carry the iPad around for its two year life expectancy, then the vast income disparities in China become more sharply focused. Such inequality poses a threat to social harmony, and if one thing absolutely pre-occupies politics in China it is maintaining social harmony.

    The target of 7.5% for 2012 reflects expectations that reduced exports due to the European crisis and a fragile US recovery could dampen growth in the world’s second-largest economy.

    It is easy to point to the Euro crisis or a stagnant US economy, or some other event happening in the West and to pin changes in China’s economic policy to them, but we shouldn’t be too quick to think that every song is about us!

  • Time to smell?

    The Financial Times reports that Paul Smith announces he is returning to the Chinese market after pulling out some five years ago.

    Sir Paul must surely at least have slightly raised an eyebrow at reports from rival British firm Burberry, which reported China as second only to the US for sales, with one of its best selling lines in China being an iPad cover costing £2,495 (more on this in the next post, Vain?).

    With China’s middle class racing to be added to the list of China’s catalogue of world’s largest, the lure of the Chinese market is self-evident, even for those who have been badly bitten by it in the past. There are two important things to draw from this. First, just how strong the gravitational pull of the Chinese market is. Paul Smith pulled out of China in 2007 after heavy losses, calling it “dangerous’. Despite such a history he is being drawn back east. Second, that we need to adjust our concept of time when we look at China. In what would seem a very short time in western markets, the whole landscape will have changed in China. As such, it may very well be time to smell.

  • Blind Justice:? The case of Gu Kailai.

    Gu Kailai, wife of the popularist politician, Bo Xilai, former Provincial Governor of Chongqing, has been given a suspended death sentence for the murder of British businessman Neil Heywood. Ms Gu had confessed to the murder, claiming that Mr Heywood had threatened her son, allegedly over a disputed £13m compensation payment Mr Heywood was claiming. Ms Gu’s accomplice, Zhang Xiaojun, was sentenced to nine years.

    According to the Telegraph :

    However, the court explained it had suspended the sentence in light of Gu’s mental state, her admissions of guilt and remorse, and her cooperation with the investigation.

    China’s judiciary isn’t averse to handing out the death sentence, nor implementing it. There is widespread support in China for this modern version of China’s legalist tradition. Public opinion in Britain is generally against the death penalty, and certainly this is government policy. The Times reported that the British government had let known that it did not wish to see the death penalty applied in this case.

    I doubt whether the wishes of the British government played much part in the sentencing of Ms Gu; if the British government couldn’t prevent the implementation of the death penalty on a British subject, then it is difficult to imagine it would have much success in influencing the outcome for a Chinese citizen.

    There’s a marked cultural difference, one we can recognise and accept as something we agree to disagree upon – in the same way as we do with the US. Yet trying to influence the outcome of Ms Gu’s sentence is perhaps a step too far. Certainly it seems difficult to justify why murderers of British subjects should be exempt from the death sentence! It flies in the face of the treasured belief that justice is blind.

  • Business sense versus the Yellow Peril.

    The business case for encouraging more Chinese tourists to the UK appears not to be strong enough to convince Home Secretary Theressa May, to make it easier for Chinese tourists to enter the UK, worryingly raising the ghost of the ‘yellow peril’ by citing national security concerns.

    A tourist visiting Britain will spend an average of£567, however, Chinese tourists spend three times that amount, averaging £1,700. Had the same number of Chinese tourists visited Britian as France last year it would have injected an extra £1,786,700,000 (yes, almost £1.8 billion) into the British economy; but it is not just the loss of a much-needed boost to the economy that should concern us.

    Suggesting that the Chinese people pose a threat to national security is difficult to understand. Neither France, Germany nor any of the twenty-plus countries that require just a single Schengen visa to visit have such qualms. Even the twitchy USA employed an extra 50 visa processing staff at its Beijing Embassy earlier this year and relaxed its visa requirements in order to attract more Chinese tourists, so no sign of any “national security” concerns there either! Sadly we should be under no doubt that the Home Secretary’s words will be heard in Beijing, and they won’t be making Britain any friends.

    Meanwhile Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt, has just launched an £8m campaign to try to attract more Chinese tourists to the UK. Last year 1.2 million Chinese tourists traveled as far as France; getting them across the Channel surely can’t be that hard… except they won’t have visas!

    What we are left with is a lose-lose situation, with a gratuitous face-losing swipe at the Chinese thrown in for good measure. With regret we return to a familiar sight, with an avoidable lack of understanding of China and the Chinese once again resulting in unnecessary damage to Britain’s standing with such an important economic partner.

  • When is a dragon not a dragon?

    The Western concept of the dragon is that of a tyrannical beast that bringing fire and destruction; it is something to be killed: Indeed, killing a dragon may well be the way to sainthood!

    In the Chinese mind the dragon is an altogether different creature. It is a bringer of good luck and bountiful harvests,  a symbol of power and wisdom.  Legend has it the Chinese are decedents of  the dragon.  If a Chinese person were to spot a dragon the last thing they would think of would be to kill it!

    How we see the world is framed by our cultural reference points.  Whilst confidence and security in who we are is essential, ignorance of others provides fertile soil for the seeds of  misunderstanding.

    A shared mythical creature and a directly translatable word, yet our understandings are about 5,000 years apart! Getting it right in China is not easy:  It isn’t easy for most Chinese! Clearly, understanding each other is more than a matter of words.